The last minute rejection of the Syrian refugee family by Indiana Gov. Mike Pence (R) is a lot of things (many of which involve curse words) but it should not be used to build court test cases that will only turn these families into victims once again.
Some people are upset that the agencies “gave in” and resettled them elsewhere (thank you, Connecticut!) rather than sending them to places where they are not wanted and would likely be treated badly. People are not symbols, they are flesh and blood and they deserve to be treated well:
[Resettlement agency] Exodus could have stuck to its guns and refused to arrange for the refugees to be redirected. That might have forced a showdown with the state government, if Pence continued to insist the state could prevent refugees from entering. More likely, though, Exodus would have had to resettle the family in Indianapolis on its own — without help from state social services.
The director of the New Haven refugee organization told the Times, “By diverting this family, we don’t want to set a precedent.” […]
The Obama administration could alleviate the resource crunch by sending non-Syrian refugees to states that reject Syrian ones — but that would be a tacit acceptance of the governors’ refusal, something President Obama doesn’t seem willing to countenance.
No, just no. THAT would be a worse precedent, allowing the states to legally discriminate based on religion and country of origin.
What we should do is to ask the State Department to add another criteria to their resettlement process: do NOT send them to states run by politicians who engage in unwelcoming rhetoric. It is a simple test, look for the “R” after their names.
The White House has some more concrete ideas …
How you can get involved:
Under President Obama, the U.S. has provided $4.5 billion in humanitarian assistance to help meet the urgent needs of those affected by the conflict, making America the world’s leading provider of much-needed aid. We are also increasing the number of Syrian and other refugees we admit from around the world on an annual basis to 100,000 in the next two years.
But this isn’t just about what a government can do. It’s about what every single one of us — as a citizen, a company, or an organization — can do to make sure that those displaced or impacted by this crisis have everything they need to survive and find safe haven.When first arriving, many refugees face the difficult task of starting a new life in a new country. As with prior generations, they are rising to this challenge with the support of a network of refugee-serving organizations located in communities across the country. These organizations provide vital services including: meeting refugees at the airport upon arrival; arranging for housing, food, and clothing; providing cultural orientation; and assisting with access to other social, medical, and employment services.
Click this link to view a map of organizations helping: Enter your zip code into the map to see where you can learn about volunteer opportunities with organizations near you that are helping refugees start anew in your community.
Clouds Over Sidra: A Virtual Reality Documentary on the Syrian Refugee Crisis
Delve into the world of a 12-year-old girl who fled Syria with her family and is living in a refugee camp in Jordan. You can click on the video to get a 360-view of what it’s like to live as a refugee and see the toll this conflict is taking on so many from her eyes.
UPDATED with pesky facts*:
ZERO: The number of Syrian refugees that have resettled in the U.S. that have been arrested or removed on terrorism charges. We can welcome refugees and ensure America’s safety and security. Slamming the door in their faces would betray our deepest values, and it’s not what we’re going to do. Get the facts at go.wh.gov/RefugeesWelcome.
*The zero is from these starting points:
– 23,092 Syrians who UNCHR has referred to the United States Refugees Admission Program
– 7,012 Syrians who were interviewed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security since fiscal year 2011
– 2,034 Syrian refugees admitted since FY 2011
And no, this is not a typo:
– 0 settled Syrian refugees who have been arrested or removed on terrorism charges.
Zero, zilch, nada. Or exactly 289 fewer than the number of United States House of Representatives members who voted to halt the resettlement program including 47 cowardly Democrats.
President Obama is steadfast in this … he will not allow the hateful rhetoric to change what our government is doing to help those fleeing oppressive regimes.
Anti-refugee rhetoric is popular and extremely popular with the Republican base:
But there is a reason we don’t allow referendums on civil rights and humanitarian aid. In 1939, 60% of Americans did not want any Jewish refugees from Europe. In 1940, people wanted Japanese-Americans interred in camps. In 1960, people did not want black Americans to be able to sit at lunch counters designated “Whites Only”.
We have a representative government and courts to cool the overheated rhetoric of popular (at the moment) sentiment.
*Note: This is an online poll and so self-selected. Also, “independents” are usually people too embarrassed to admit that they are Republicans. I will be watching for a Pew poll.
Religious groups are at odds with their political party:
The head of the Catholic bishops expresses “dismay” that a party of nativist racists would be nativist racists!!
Wake up and smell the stench emanating from your party, Bishop, the Party of Trump … and Cruz … and Ryan … and Christie.
Senate Democrats want to focus on security, not refugees. For example, the NRA refuses to back down on insisting that terrorists can buy guns:
Maybe those people should be stopped from doing that instead of blocking 3 year old orphans from entering our country?
More Democratic reaction:
So these big ol’ strong Rethug he-men, who could stare down Putin and make short work of Daesh, are scared of five-year-old children and their mothers?
UGH! I would be so ashamed to call myself a Rethug!
Uh…that guy named Jesus…wasn’t he brown-skinned, with long hair and a beard and bare, dusty feet? Would they have kept him out of the country?
Too disgusted to write any more. May lightning strike the scant-souled.
President Obama’s response to Paul Ryan’s bill the so-called SAFE Act:
Among other things.
From Missouri: Lawmaker calls for legislature to stop ‘Islamization of Missouri’ by Syrian refugees
Gov. Jay Nixon, a Democrat, has already said that Missouri would continue to accept refugees.
This is what I think about when I read these stories about refusal to take in Syrian refugees. My former in-laws – the parents of my ex-husband – were German Jews, living in Berlin before WWII. Ken’s mother was sent to England in the Kindertransport in the mid-30s (I think that was the timing) at about the age of 12, because England would take SOME Jewish children but not their parents. Her parents very fortunately got out to Shanghai at the start of the war, where they suffered terribly during the Japanese occupation but did survive to be reunited with Miriam after the war. Ken’s father and his parents were in Berlin up to the summer of 1941, desperately trying to get out to the US where they had some sort of relative, I was never clear on the connection. The US would NOT take in Jews fleeing persecution except under very rare circumstances – miraculously, this relative managed to get them US visas in August of 1941, and they crossed occupied France in a sealed train, bearing passports with the yellow Star of David on them, and got a boat that took them from Lisbon to New York. 6 months later, after Pearl Harbor, Ken’s father was drafted, at age 18 and speaking very little English, and sent to England where he was a guard at German POW camps. He met Ken’s mother there, and brought her back to the US as a war bride.
They were the very, very lucky ones – the rest of their extended families in Germany and elsewhere in Europe were murdered by the Nazis. I don’t know how many might have made it to this country and other safe havens if policies had been different, but perhaps hundreds of thousands of European Jews died because this country and others REFUSED to give them sanctuary. The United States, a nation of immigrants, gave in to xenophobia and anti-Semitism, and thus was complicit in those deaths, to my way of thinking.
This is all I can think about when I read about these disgusting Republican governors trying to keep refugees out of their states – my ex-husband is alive ONLY because some rare chance allowed his parents to find sanctuary from the barbarism of the Nazis. Are we not better than that now? Seriously? I mean, I know there are security issues, sure – – but we screen these people. Are 5 year old children really going to pose a threat? It disgusts me so much, I can barely stand to think about it. Great posts as always JanF
The Republicans are so desperate to gain an electoral upper hand that they have jettisoned their humanity. In a just world, there would be a price to pay. I hope payment comes due sooner rather than later as all the effort President Obama has put into restoring America’s reputation in the world after the Bush doctrine shredded it is at risk of being lost.
No, we are not better than that now. The same ideas that refused asylum to Jews in the 1930s are alive and well today. What progress we’ve made in any kind of human rights has been because of a minority of very determined people like Denise who had more “yes” than the racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic majority had “no”. And every time the latter get frightened there’s a lot of backsliding and a whole lot of work that has to be done again.
What a moving post, Geordie. So glad that your ex-husband and at least some of his children escaped.
The ugliness of some people surpasseth all understanding.
Well at least there is some good news
Don’t ‘scapegoat’ Syrian refugees, Catholic bishops and evangelicals say
Should be interesting to hear R response to this – since some of the R candidates claim to be evangelical.
They’re only evangelical when they can use it as an excuse.
This would not be the first time that Republican lawmakers ignored the teachings of their spiritual leaders.
Churches and bibles are handy for photo ops to dupe the dupable. Their instructions come from the NRA and the military industrial complex.
Secretary Clinton at the Council on Foreign Relations today:
This afternoon, the House passed the Americans SAFE Act with 47 Democratic votes. Harry Reid said it will not get through cloture in thw Senate. In any event, the president will veto it.
Another show vote to hang up there on the wall with the 60+ ACA repeals and use in fundraising letters.
Jan, LOVE your “Updated with pesky facts” subtitle!
Still smiling at that, but not at what’s being reported.
Here are some more:
From what I have seen about the Daesh, patience is not one of their qualities. No one is going to sit in a refugee camp for 2 years on the off chance that they will be able to pass the vetting and become the lucky 1 out of 10 chosen to be resettled … just so that they can blow up some stuff in America.
And these pesky facts:
Not Muslim:
Hindu:
Probably Christian:
I think they are just not looking hard enough for the ties that bind those folks together. It may not be a specific organization every time but there is a pattern: anti-government, often white supremacist … angry white men.
Regardless, not just Muslims.